| California Pizza KitchenButter Cake 1 order | |
| White CastleGooey Butter Cake 1 order (57g) | |
| Sara LeeClassic Pound Cake 1⁄4 cake (76g) | |
|
|
| Pound CakePrepared w/ butter 1 piece (61g) | |
| Jeni'sGooey Butter Cake Ice Cream 2⁄3 cup (123g) | |
| Huddle HouseSouthern Pecan Cake w/ Butter Blend 1 order | |
| H-E-BWhite Cake w/ Confetti & Butter Cream Icing 1⁄8 cake (84g) | |
| Entenmann'sAll Butter Loaf Cake 1⁄6 loaf (54g) | |
| PublixButter Pound CakeFound in bakery department 1 slice (24g) | |
| QuakerButter Popcorn Rice Cake 1 cake (9g) | |
| Sweet StreetChocolate Peanut Butter Stack Cake 1 piece (147g) | |
| TastykakeButtercreme Filled Chocolate Cupkakes 2 cakes (67g) | |
| Denny'sButtermilk Pancakes w/ MargarineBuild Your Own Grand Slam 2 cakes | |
|
|
| KodiakPeanut Butter Crunchy Granola Bar 2 bars (45g) | |
| TastykakeButterscotch Krimpets 2 cakes (57g) | |
| Stop & ShopMarble Butter Pound Cake 1⁄8 cake | |
| H-E-BChocolate Cake w/ Confetti Buttercream Icing 0.2 cake (80g) | |
| Wegmans7" Round One Layer Vanilla Celebration Cake w/ Butter Cream 1⁄6 cake (90g) | |
| Cheesecake FactoryReese's Peanut Butter Chocolate Cake Cheesecake 1 slice | |
| WegmansPeanut Butter Brownie Cake Slices 1 brownie (142g) | |
| TastykakePeanut Butter Kandy Kakes 2 cakes (38g) | |
| Sara LeeClassic Pound CakeFamily size 1⁄6 cake (76g) | |
| Betty CrockerButter Recipe Yellow CakePrepared from mix. Icing not included. 1 slice (1/10 package) | |
|
|
| NordstromPineapple Brown Butter Cake 1 order (214g) | |
| Cold Stone CreamerySmall Round Cake – Peanut Butter Playground 1⁄8 cake (152g) | |
| Betty CrockerButter Pecan Cake MixMix only 0.1 package (43g) | |
| Bob EvansHotcakes w/ Butter & Syrup 1 order | |
| TastykakeMini Peanut Butter Swirly Chocolate Cupcakes 3 cakes (43g) | |
| Cooking LightYellow Butter Cake w/ Vanilla Meringue Frosting 1 slice | |
| PublixCoconut Cake w/ Butter Cream IcingFound in bakery department 0.1 cake (79g) | |
| H-E-BWhite Cake w/ Strawberry French Buttercream 1 slice (217g) | |
| Huddle HouseWild Blueberry Cake w/ Butter Blend 1 order | |
| Impromptu GourmetPeanut Butter Cup Cake 1 slice (177g) | |
|
|
| KodiakMaple Almond Butter Syrup 2 tbsp | |
| TastykakeDark Chocolate Peanut Butter Kandy Kakes 2 cakes | |
| Entenmann'sUltimate Madeleines 2 cakes (52g) | |
| Mimi's Bistro & BakeryBirthday Crêpe Cake 1 order | |
| PublixButter Pound CakeFound in bakery department 1⁄4 cake (85g) | |
| H-E-BDanish Butter Loaf Cake w/ Streusel Topping 2 slices (57g) | |
| HostessPeanut Butter Ding Dongs 2 cakes (84g) | |
| Europa CafePeanut Butter Cup Cupcake 1 cupcake (223g) | |
| Sara LeeButter Streusel Coffee Cake 1⁄6 cake (54g) | |
| Duncan HinesButter Recipe Fudge CakePrepared from mix. Icing not included. 0.1 cake | |
| Duncan HinesButter Golden CakePrepared from mix. Icing not included. 0.1 cake | |
| Cold Stone CreameryLarge Round Cake – Peanut Butter Playground 0.071 cake (137g) | |
| Cold Stone CreamerySmall Rectangle Cake – Peanut Butter Playground 0.04 cake (142g) | |
| Cold Stone CreameryLarge Rectangle Cake – Peanut Butter Playground 0.025 cake (123g) | |
| Betty CrockerButter Recipe Yellow Cake MixMix only 0.1 package (43g) | |
| PillsburyGolden Butter Premium Cake MixMoist supreme. Dry mix only. 0.1 package (43g) | |
| Duncan HinesButter Golden Cake MixAs packaged 0.1 container (43g) | |
| Duncan HinesButter Recipe Fudge Cake MixAs packaged 0.1 container (43g) | |
| Entenmann'sButter French Crumb Cake 1⁄6 cake (66g) | |
| Mimi's Bistro & BakeryGriddle CakesKids' menu 1 order | |
| KodiakChocolate Peanut Butter Flapjack Cup 1 container (67g) | |
| KodiakPeanut Butter Power CakesFlapjack & waffle mix 0.5 cup (53g) | |
| Cold Stone CreameryGooey Butter Cake Ice Cream 1 like it (142g) | |
| Cold Stone CreameryGooey Butter Cake Ice Cream 1 love it (227g) | |
| Cold Stone CreameryGooey Butter Cake Ice Cream 1 gotta have it (227g) | |
| Cold Stone CreameryPetite Cake – Peanut Butter Playground 0.5 cake (194g) | |
| KodiakMaple Peanut Butter Syrup 2 tbsp | |
| Stop & ShopButter Pound Cake 1⁄8 cake | |
| Duncan HinesChocolate Peanut Butter Mug Cake 1 pouch (68g) | |
| Big YButter Popcorn Rice Cake 1 cake (10g) | |
| Simple TruthCake Batter Cashew Nut Butter Bites 3 pieces (33g) | |
| Huddle HouseButter Pecan Praline Cake 1 order | |
| Not Your Average Joe'sPeanut Butter Thing Ice Cream Cake 1 order | |
| ComplimentsButter Loaf Cake 1⁄7 cake (55g) | |
| OnePeanut Butter Chocolate Cake Bar 1 bar (60g) | |
| Betty CrockerButter Recipe Chocolate Cake MixMix only 0.1 package (43g) | |
| Betty CrockerButter Recipe Chocolate CakePrepared from mix. Icing not included. 1 slice (1/10 package) | |
| Betty CrockerButter Pecan CakePrepared from mix. Icing not included. 1 slice (1/10 package) | |
| KodiakChocolate Peanut Butter Brownie Cup 1 container (67g) | |
| The Protein BakeryPeanut Butter Cake 1 slice (1/10 cake) | |
| Huddle HouseOld Fashioned Buttermilk Cake w/ Butter Blend 1 order | |
| Huddle HouseChocolate Chip Fix Cake w/ Butter Blend 1 order | |
| WegmansPeanut Butter Brownie Cake 0.067 cake (77g) | |
| Good Times BurgersButter Pecan Frozen Custard 1 cake cone | |
